Main navigation

Bitcoin (BTC) Under Satoshi Nakamoto Could Have Been Security Too: XRP Holders' Lawyer

Sun, 04/02/2023 - 12:09
article image
Gamza Khanzadaev
John Deaton is convinced that even Bitcoin could have been recognized as security if this had happened in Satoshi Nakamoto's time
Bitcoin (BTC) Under Satoshi Nakamoto Could Have Been Security Too: XRP Holders' Lawyer
Cover image via
Read U.TODAY on
Google News

If Satoshi Nakamoto had offered to sell 100,000 BTC for $100,000 when he was the only or one of the only Bitcoin miners, it would have been considered an offer of unregistered securities, John Deaton believes. This is the opinion that accompanied the pro-crypto lawyer and legal representative for XRP holders' latest criticism of U.S. regulators regarding the cryptocurrency market and current legislation in this area.

Ripple's Alderoty Urges Caution Before Joining Sen. Warren's Anti-Crypto Campaign

The lawyer's tirade began by saying that the term "investment contract" used by regulators like the SEC to define some cryptocurrencies is one of the most misunderstood terms in law right now, and the Howey test used to define a security is just as misapplied. It is noteworthy that both these subjects of law predate the middle of the 20th century, a point also highlighted by the lawyer.

In his opinion, for the cryptocurrency itself, it does not matter how it was distributed, like Ethereum (ETH) through an ICO or like XRP sold by Ripple. The method of distribution, even if it is recognized as an offering of unregistered securities, does not make the asset itself, in this case the digital code, such, Deaton says.

Ripple CEO Garlinghouse Urges US Lawmakers to Address SEC Chair's Assertions

If we follow the logic promoted by regulators, it would appear that every altcoin is a security at the time of its distribution, Deaton concludes, citing the example of Bitcoin.

article image
About the author

Financial analyst, trader and crypto enthusiast.

Gamza graduated with a degree in finance and credit with a specialization in securities and financial derivatives. He then also completed a master's program in banking and asset management.

He wants to have a hand in covering economic and fintech topics, as well as educate more people about cryptocurrencies and blockchain.