Main navigation

Is XRPL Decentralized? Analyst Shares Critical Take

Fri, 12/23/2022 - 16:45
article image
Vladislav Sopov
Seasoned analyst Justin Bons yet again explains why XRP Ledger design is far from being decentralized
Is XRPL Decentralized? Analyst Shares Critical Take
Cover image via stock.adobe.com
Read U.TODAY on
Google News
Contents

Analyst Justin Bons, a cryptocurrency veteran and head of the oldest European blockchain fund Cyber Capital, explains why decentralization narratives do not work for XRP Ledger.

Ripple is centralized, PoA cannot be trustless

Mr. Bons has taken to Twitter to share that XRP Ledger blockchain is not permissionless, as it relies on a permissioned ecosystem of nodes selected by centralized entities or individuals.

This proof-of-authority design is not equal to real "trustleness," Mr. Bons highlights. In XRPL's consensus, individuals delegate too much power to participants of the block validation process:

I disagree that replacing PoW/PoS with individuals choosing who they trust is trustless.

Ripple alum Matt Hamilton of Protocol Labs opposed Mr. Bons' theory. He highlighted that neither Ripple nor XRPL Foundation could prevent a blockchain enthusiast from becoming a validator of XRP transactions.

As per Mr. Hamilton, XRP Ledger's version of PoA represents the same type of social contract as the one used by all first-gen blockchains, including Bitcoin (BTC) and its forks.

Why UNL rules matter

The two opponents disagreed about the role of XRPL Foundation's Unique Node List (UNL), i.e., its set of active XRP transaction validators.

Mr. Bons highlighted that validation power on XRP Ledger is only controlled by members of the "official" UNL. Meanwhile, in October 2022, XRPL Foundation, the nonprofit that oversees XRPL's development, stressed that two Ripple-associated validators were removed from UNL.

Related
XRP Ledger Updated Its UNL: What Does This Mean?

After this amendment, Ripple and its entities only control 2 out of 35 validators, or less than 5.8% of its total distributed computational power.

article image
About the author

Blockchain Analyst & Writer with scientific background. 6+ years in IT-analytics, 3+ years in blockchain.

Worked in independent analysis as well as in start-ups (Swap.online, Monoreto, Attic Lab etc.)