Next Facebook will be Federation of Decentralized Networks: Bill Ottman of

  • Katya Michaels
    🎤 Interviews

    What can be a strategy for the future of social media?

Next Facebook will be Federation of Decentralized Networks: Bill Ottman of
You may also like:

The Cambridge Analytica scandal and Mark Zuckerberg’s Senate hearings brought issues of privacy and data ownership starkly into the public eye, prompting even the least technologically advanced users to give some thought to the way their information is being used by major media companies.

Bill Ottman was quite ahead of the curve, launching Minds in 2011 with the aim of creating a different social network – one that would not only let users post the genius exploits of their pets, but also foster a certain kind of community with a specific set of values.

While Minds has enjoyed slow but steady organic growth over the years, the increasing awareness of decentralized technologies could now put Minds into the spotlight. It might not single-handedly topple Facebook overnight, but that’s not how Bill Ottman sees the future of social media, anyway.

👉MUST READ CryptoKitties Co-Founder Benny Giang: Spend a Week Understanding Why Crypto Matters to You
CryptoKitties Co-Founder Benny Giang: Spend a Week Understanding Why Crypto Matters to You

Katya Michaels: You started Minds in 2011, the web and mobile apps were launched in June 2015. What has been happening since then?

Bill Ottman: We have been constantly growing– over a million users now. It’s mostly steady organic growth, with a few big jumps based around big privacy breaches or changes in algorithms on major social networks. These types of events cause people to search for alternatives.

We considered it very unethical what Facebook did with their algorithm.

It used to be possible to drive a lot of traffic to websites through Facebook, but with algorithm changes, you couldn't even reach your own fans anymore. This really affected the whole media industry.

Now, small to medium sized creators are finding it easier to grow an audience on Minds than on Facebook, even though we are literally a thousandth of the size because we have a way to break out of the void.

When we launched in 2015, we had a point system for boosting posts. This quickly became the most popular feature on the network. Now, our Ethereum-based token system works essentially the same way, but on a Blockchain. We reward people for the engagement that they receive and referrals that they make.

Then, they can use those tokens to boost their posts through the platform or through other users. For example, they can offer another user 100 tokens to share a photo – it’s pure peer to peer advertising with no middleman. An application concurrent with tokens is a crowdfunding tool, so creators can set tiers of rewards and offer monthly subscriptions with exclusive content.

👉MUST READ Vinny Lingham On Bitcoin Future and Next Crypto Star: Exclusive to CryptoComes
Vinny Lingham On Bitcoin Future and Next Crypto Star: Exclusive to CryptoComes

KM: Where are you with your token? How do you expect it to be affected by regulations?

BO: Currently we're on the Ethereum Link testnet. These are not real tokens yet. We're doing going through extensive security auditing to make sure all of our smart contracts are rock solid and consulting with legal.

Before we implemented crypto over the last six months, users could send each other points or  dollars with Stripe. We took all of that out to focus fully on crypto and our revenue in the future is going to be in tokens.

On day one of any potential token sale, the tokens will be immediately usable. There will be no future products, we're not doing any kind of presales, we're not doing lockup. We're really trying to check off all the boxes to fall into the utility category.

I'm actually glad that we waited because a lot of social apps that have launched crypto over the last year are in a difficult situation now because they did SAFT agreements for future tokens or they didn't have a product.

👉MUST READ What is DAICO? Incorporating Features of DAO and ICO
What is DAICO? Incorporating Features of DAO and ICO

KM: When Minds got started seven years ago, there were fewer people who recognized the issues with major platforms like Facebook. Will rising awareness of privacy breaches and Blockchain technologies give decentralized platforms a boost?

BO: Absolutely. Without spending money on marketing, we're seeing fully organic growth directly in line with Cambridge Analytica or similar events. I think that people are becoming much more aware, they're starting to care more.

We think people deserve to be rewarded for their energy. Facebook, Google, Twitter, proprietary social media – they have an extractive model. They're assuming that you're lucky to be using the platform for free and they're going to use your data as your form of compensation.

Now, people are starting to understand that users, influencers, content creators are valuable. The people are actually what constitutes the network. Some of these independent creators on Youtube have more social reach than CNN. They are big brands, and the proprietary networks have to be very careful about driving them away.

Our strategy is the reward mechanism. Earning tokens for your contribution – that's something that everyone cares about, even if you're into Internet freedom, privacy and open source technology.

There’s a learning curve with crypto. First you need to appeal a little to the common human aspect, and as they come to the platform, they are exposed to the other layers of value such as freedom, privacy, transparency.

👉MUST READ Ripple’s David Schwartz: What Bitcoin and Ethereum Should Do to Catch Up With Ripple
Ripple’s David Schwartz: What Bitcoin and Ethereum Should Do to Catch Up With Ripple

KM: Facebook has billions of users and they're not going to offload en masse anytime soon. How does Minds face the adoption challenge? Would you try to get big content creators to come over?

BO: We already have some big Youtubers and Twitter influencers on the platform A lot of our big growth spurts are when a content creator with a million followers says “follow me on Minds” and overnight we will see 25,000 more users.

Certainly, the influencers hold a huge amount of the power. That is where the waves of migration to more decentralized, incentivized networks will come from.

👉MUST READ Federico Pistono: Bitcoin’s Power Structure is Very Robust, Altcoins Are Test Bed
 Federico Pistono: Bitcoin’s Power Structure is Very Robust, Altcoins Are Test Bed

KM: I feel there would be a self-selection process for decentralized social network adoption, with people who are more concerned about data ownership being more likely to make the switch.

BO: For sure. Probably 90 percent of our current user base are people who are very aware of these issues and personally invested in helping to build solutions. We had an equity crowdfunding round last year, actually setting the record in the US for fastest to raise a million – and it all came from 1500 members of our community. That's a lot of people who are invested in these causes and are willing to become shareholders.

KM: Some new entertainment platforms are trying to change the advertising model to a framework where users choose to engage with advertising and get rewarded for it. Is that something that Minds is considering – third party advertisement for token compensation?

BO: We're certainly looking into having users watch ads and get compensated for that, with a distribution model that will support the creator as well. But we're staying away from third-party ad networks. We actually built our own internal ad network specifically because of issues with surveillance. I would say probably 99 percent of ad networks out there are basically spyware.

KM: With user generated content, there are always going to be issues with content quality control, legal considerations. How is Minds handling that? What is your stance on curation and censorship?

BO: In terms of copyright, we handle it like anyone else. If we get a DMCA request, we take content down, but that hasn't been much of a problem at all. We spent a lot of time over the last year working on our reporting, blocking and filtering tools, so that users can have as much control over their experience as possible.

This is actually one of my main interests right now – content policy and the best strategy for diminishing hate speech online.

Dozens of studies show that censorship amplifies hate speech.

Networks that have extensive hate speech policies think that they're fixing the problem, but what's actually happening is that they aggravate the trolls and the discussions get inflamed. If you look at the rise of political polarization in the last year or two, it is directly related to what's happening on Youtube and Twitter and Facebook.

We're not standing up for free speech just for the sake of it – we believe this is the strategy the Internet needs on a long-term macro basis. We have that larger mission to not polarize politically and create an honest, open and positive tone for the network.

People really appreciate that, even if they have drastically different ideas.

👉MUST READ Facebook Token: Can the Media Giant Disrupt Itself? Expert Opinion
Facebook Token: Can the Media Giant Disrupt Itself? Expert Opinion

KM: That’s a very challenging thing to do because it seems like the system selects for extremity, and then it becomes difficult to defend moderate positions.

BO: I can't agree more. It's called the Streisand effect – when you silence something, it makes it louder. If you ban books, it makes people want to read them more. It's certainly tricky, but the right to freedom of speech and First Amendment protection exists for the purpose of defending ideas that most people find controversial. You don't need freedom of speech for things most people agree with.

I do think that we need to start having this conversation with the bigger networks. Reddit knows as much as anyone that the amplification of extremism happens when you censor, but they’ve gone down the rabbit hole over the last couple of years, censoring things arbitrarily. They've fallen away from where they originally were, and so has Twitter. It's very hard because the public pressure to cave is intense.

KM: A lot of these social media companies started out as mavericks, giving users freedom of expression, but years go by, they get big and they become the establishment. Do you think that’s something that can affect crypto and Blockchain companies as well?

BO: Well, look at what just happened to Coinbase– it banned Julian Assange. First he got banned from PayPal and there was a big uproar. Then he started taking donations in Bitcoin, and now Coinbase said no.

That's a perfect example of a crypto company that ends up becoming the establishment, but it’s very nuanced. Nuance for me is the word of the year, if not the last few years.

Obviously Coinbase is essential to the growth of crypto in general and it's a great company, but it’s also fully, totally proprietary. They've had transparency issues a little bit over the years.

Now there are also issues with privacy and Blockchain because Blockchain is immutable and forever. When people talk about publishing things to the Blockchain, but then wanting to delete them – you're getting into a complicated situation. Which would you prefer? The ability to delete or the decentralized power of the blockchain?

👉MUST READ CryptoComes Women in Blockchain: Crystal Rose on Blockchain Island, Governance and Open Data
CryptoComes Women in Blockchain: Crystal Rose on Blockchain Island, Governance and Open Data

KM: What's the roadmap for Minds over the next months? What are you hoping for?

BO: We're certainly aiming for a token sale this year. I think that we are seeing other examples like Steemit working – the SEC is not taking them down. Also, we are definitely focusing on further decentralization, but balancing that with the nuance of privacy versus the immutability that comes with Blockchain.

Our technology is fully open source and decentralized, so anyone can take our stack and start their own app. That's really important because those apps can be independent, but they can also potentially federate together.

We don't see the next Facebook being a singular centralized entity. It really can't be. Realistically it's going to be some sort of a federation – whether it's a federation of networks or individuals in control of their own data joining networks that are a decentralized.

👉MUST READ Past ICO Review: What Remains From Bancor’s Initial Boom
Past ICO Review: What Remains From Bancor’s Initial Boom

KM: So you see the future of media as stepping back from monopolization – being fragmented, but interoperable?

BO: For sure. It’s naive to expect everything in social media to be decentralized all at once. Sure, that's a great goal to have. But pragmatically and realistically, there's a reason that it hasn't been achieved yet. A lot of this tech is still very immature.

There's value in having a big community and making the process easy for everyone. Our strategy is more of centralization moving towards decentralization, as opposed to starting off in a scattered mess and trying to get everyone involved that way.

In order for Blockchain and open source, privacy networks to compete with Facebook, we have an obligation to become competitive functionally.

We're getting much closer. Our mobile apps are much better, we have a lot of the tools that they have. If you look at what's happening with Instagram, Snapchat, Google – all these apps tend to coalesce, they have the same features and compete with each other. What we want to do is provide those services, but with a different set of core values.

👉MUST READ How to Prevent Attackers From Hacking Blockchain Nodes: Professor of Cryptography Opinion
How to Prevent Attackers From Hacking Blockchain Nodes: Professor of Cryptography Opinion

Cover image via
In this Telegram channel you’ll find fresh news, interviews, infographics, forecasts & other helpful stuff. Join U.Today's channel.
👓 Recommended articles

Between Green and Red: Coin360 CEO Evan Ropp Talks Competition with CoinMarketCap and Future Altcoin Takeover

  • Alex Morris
    🎤 Interviews

    Coin360 CEO Evan Ropp claims that IEOs, stablecoins and institutional money will define the industry in 2019

Between Green and Red: Coin360 CEO Evan Ropp Talks Competition with CoinMarketCap and Future Altcoin Takeover
You may also like:

During the periods of extreme volatility, crypto enthusiasts try to keep tabs on every single market move. The market visualization from Coin360 vividly shows where the cryptocurrency market is heading at any given moment.

Coin360 CEO Evan Ropp revealed exclusively to U.Today about how he came up with the idea of the instantly recognizable treemap design. He also weighed in on a slew of tangible issues that pertain to his fledgling startup and the overall state of the cryptocurrency market.

U.Today: Hi, Evan! How did you come up with the idea of market visualization in the form a treemap?

Evan Ropp: Actually, the idea is not quite new. This type of visualization is popular on stocks trading resources and we just applied it to the cryptocurrency market. However, the cryptocurrency market is slightly different than the stock market, so we had to redesign some of the features. For instance, on COIN360 you can find filters which are different from other price trackers. Also, we added a function for creating up to five different watchlists, which our users find really helpful.

The website interface of Coin360
The market is plateauing with Bitcoin and altcoins barely recording any price gains, image by Coin360

U.Today: Do you think you can compete with CoinMarketCap and CoinGecko?

Evan Ropp: The main focus of our team is on providing our users with the best experience. We understand that CoinMarketCap and CoinGecko are market leaders. So we just want to develop our product without altering user behavior, but instead making our product faster, simpler, and smoother to use. For that, we update COIN360 and add new features quite often, for example, recently we updated the coin/token card. Also, we are always improving the mobile version of the site to make it work smoother. We are focused on developing our product because I am convinced that in this respect we can get ahead of market leaders.

U.Today: When do you plan to introduce other fiat currencies?

Evan Ropp: We have always had USD in the Base Currency section and recently we have added EUR, GBP and CNY. Additionally, the COIN360 team is planning to launch more fiats: there will be 29 additional currencies. The Base Currency section update is tentatively scheduled for the second quarter of this year.

U.Today: Was it technically difficult for you to implement the auto-update option? Where do you get your data from?  

Evan Ropp: First of all, yes, it wasn’t easy. We needed to rewrite and optimize our back and front end code. Secondly, we have developed our own API which is connected to exchanges. We are gathering all the data on our side. We will continue developing to consolidate our position on top of the market.

U.Today: Do COIN360 visitors use your new bubble-like map? Do you plan to introduce new similar features?

Evan Ropp: We had to remove our bubble-view map. We launched it in September 2018 and it seemed like a great idea. Moreover, none of our crypto competitors had a bubble view, but in fact, its usability wasn't so good. The feedback we got from our users suggested that the treemap and a common table view are way more convenient to use. However, we do have a die-hard bubble-view map fan, so we worked out something special for him.

U.Today: You occasionally post Infographics on your social media platforms. Do you plan to make more of them in the future?  

Evan Ropp: COIN360 is about bringing data in the most understandable visual form. We see that our users and followers really like these infographics as well as the platform itself. So, we are planning to make infographics more frequently and publish them on our Twitter. We will also conduct more complex research to give our users more unique insights.

Bitcoin’s had a wild ride in 2018 with many rises and falls   
One of the COIN360’s recent Infographics, image by Coin360

U.Today: You’ve previously mentioned that Grin is one of your favorite currencies. Do you think it has the potential to surpass other privacy coins?  

Evan Ropp: I really like Grin, it is a breath of fresh air for the industry. Also, I really appreciate that the overall supply is unlimited because Grin uses a linear supply schedule of inflation, so this has users spending not to just hodl. In my opinion, Grin has been adequately developed for the long term and not just for speculative short-run reasons. Can Grin surpass other privacy coins? I believe so, but it has to become more user-friendly.

U.Today: What crypto trends will define 2019?  

Evan Ropp: I’m not a fortune teller, but there are some things that I think are likely in 2019.

First, I would focus on the Initial Exchange Offering (IEO). This may help startups and other companies raise money. There is not enough trust in ICOs, but the names and brands of exchanges can attract new people and money to the industry.

Second, I’d like to mention stablecoins. There are many people who are interested in the cryptocurrency market but they are afraid of high volatility. Stablecoins might be the solution.

Third, you have to look at institutional investors. I hope that we will see more professional services when Bakkt gets launched. If just a small percentage of institutional clients would enter the crypto market I think we’d be looking at a new bull run.

U.Today: Do you get upset when Bitcoin hits a snag and the whole site turns red?

That’s a nice question. I get more upset not when BTC goes down but when the whole site turns red. There is a strong correlation between BTC and altcoins. I hope this will change and altcoins won’t be so dependent on Bitcoin. By the way, when COIN360 turns red I’m just setting custom period of time to turn it to green (laughing).

U.Today: Will Bitcoin remain the biggest currency on your site in the long run? What coin could replace it?

I suppose, that in ten years Bitcoin will still be the number one coin in terms of market capitalization. I really would like to see new technologies and solutions on the market. Hopefully, in ten years, Bitcoin’s dominance will fall to 20% of market capitalization. Regarding particular currencies, I believe in the EOS project. XRP also has nice chances because it has the highest level of confidence from institutional investors.

Cover image via
Only the most important posts per day. Infographics, analytics, reviews & summaries. Join our Telegram channel!
👓 Recommended articles