Are Ripple's XRP, Stellar, and EOS Securities? Top Crypto Exchanges Join Forces to Determine This

Mon, 09/30/2019 - 14:13
Alex Dovbnya
Coinbase, Kraken and other US crypto exchanges have formed a council to determine which cryptocurrencies are more likely to be securities
Cover image via

While the US Securities and Exchanges Commission (SEC) struggles to come up with proper regulations for digital currencies, the leading cryptocurrency exchanges have decided to take the matter into their own hands.

According to an article published by the WSJ, the Crypto Ratings Council (CRC) will include such big names as Coinbase, Kraken, Circle, and Grayscale.

Ripple Executive Makes a Pitch for Cryptocurrency Regulations in the US: ‘We Are Well Beyond the Days of Silk Road’

Grading cryptocurrencies 

Starting from Sept. 30, each digital asset will be given a mark that ranges from 1 to 5. The companies behind these tokens are not supposed to have a say in the grading process, but they can alleviate it by providing the council with more information.      

The SEC has already confirmed that Bitcoin is not a security. Hence, the coin that started it all was given a 1, and it will serve as a litmus paper to determine how other coins should be regulated.

Maker, Polymath, and Ripple’s XRP are so far the only coins that scored a 4 or higher. Recently, Ripple sought to drop its class-action lawsuit due to its expiration.      

Notably, the cryptocurrencies that got a 5 rating will not be disclosed by the group.    

Bringing more clarity  

Coinbase has already been using this novel grading system for six months, which allowed it to list significantly more coins over the same period of time. The company also encouraged competing exchanges to follow suit.     

Brian Brooks, a chief legal officer at Coinbase, says that asset managers tend to stay away from cryptocurrencies because of regulatory uncertainty.

One of the biggest uncertainties around crypto and the reason why more asset managers are not comfortable with it is the uncertainty around which is a security and which is not.”

Although the CRC’s failed to secure the SEC’s endorsement, they hope that this will be regarded as a “positive step” by the regulator, according to Kraken’s general counsel Mary Beth Buchanan.

About the author

Alex Dovbnya (aka AlexMorris) is a cryptocurrency expert, trader and journalist with extensive experience of covering everything related to the burgeoning industry — from price analysis to Blockchain disruption. Alex authored more than 1,000 stories for U.Today, CryptoComes and other fintech media outlets. He’s particularly interested in regulatory trends around the globe that are shaping the future of digital assets, can be contacted at

This site uses cookies for different purposes. Please set your preferences in Cookie Settings and visit our Cookie policy for more information on how and why cookies are used on this site. Click here for cookie policy

Cookie settings